indiancritic
Subscribe

The Archies Proved That Nepotism’s Real Advantage Is Permission to Be Unready

Zoya Akhtar built a gorgeous, affectionate Riverdale, but several highly promoted debuts lacked the command the material demanded. The problem is not famous parents by themselves; it is an industry that treats access as proof of readiness.

Kabir Malhotra
· 6 min read
The Archies Proved That Nepotism’s Real Advantage Is Permission to Be Unready
Mollsmolyneux at en.wikipedia / CC BY-SA 3.0

Advertisement

I wanted to like The Archies. Its colours have confidence, its production design has wit, and Zoya Akhtar’s decision to place Riverdale inside an Anglo-Indian hill town is more imaginative than the lazy remake factory Bollywood usually calls adaptation. The film’s official Netflix listing describes a 1960s story about friendship, romance and a threatened park. On paper, this is precisely the kind of clean, crafted musical Hindi cinema should be able to make. Yet I kept noticing the strain whenever charm had to become performance. A film designed to introduce several young actors ended up demonstrating the difference between being launchable and being ready.

Access is not the crime; immunity is

The nepotism debate becomes stupid when it insists that every child of a film family must be talentless. Art does not obey genetics in either direction. Some star children are terrific actors; some outsiders are wooden. Famous parents can provide cultural fluency without guaranteeing skill. My objection is not that Suhana Khan, Khushi Kapoor or Agastya Nanda were allowed to audition. It is that Bollywood’s launch system often builds an entire project around privileged entrants before the audience has seen evidence that they can carry it.

Netflix’s cast announcement presented seven young performers as a fresh ensemble. That language is technically true and industrially revealing. Some members arrived with far greater media capital than others. Long before release, coverage treated certain debuts as events. The publicity machine did not merely introduce actors; it transferred inherited curiosity into presumed significance.

That advantage would bother me less if the industry admitted it. Instead, we hear fairy tales about everyone being equally nervous at an audition. Of course privileged newcomers work hard. Hard work and advantage coexist. The chauffeur does not perform the scene, but access buys time, training, insulation from rent and repeated opportunities after failure. Most crucially, it buys permission to be unready in public.

The film’s polish magnified the weak spots

The Archies is visually controlled. Costumes, choreography, sets and songs occupy one aesthetic universe. That control creates pleasure, but it also exposes actors who cannot generate inner life beneath the arrangement. In a musical, performers must make stylisation feel spontaneous. They need rhythm even while speaking, and distinct personality even when the frame is busy. Too often I saw attractive young people executing instructions rather than characters wanting something.

Vedang Raina and Mihir Ahuja appeared more relaxed because they understood that screen presence is not a pose one holds; it is attention moving between people. Dot brought an eccentric specificity. Elsewhere, line readings landed softly when scenes needed bite. Emotional turns were indicated rather than lived. No scandal occurred. The performances were simply not consistently strong enough to justify the scale of their introduction.

I blame casting and development more than the actors. A newcomer cannot know what a production protects them from seeing. Directors and producers decide whether a performance is ready. If months of workshops still produce uneven command, the honest response is to recast, reduce the role or delay the project. Bollywood instead treats the launch date as sacred because too many reputations are invested in it.

Classic Hindi cinema understood apprenticeship

I love old Hindi films without pretending the past was meritocratic. Families, camps and patronage have always existed. But many actors developed through theatre, supporting roles, dance companies or years of minor work before the camera declared them stars. The industry had room for character actors whose craft sharpened the leads. Today, publicity often demands instant centrality. The newcomer’s first appearance must be a brand origin story.

That pressure harms privileged actors too. They are introduced under a microscope, carrying surnames the screenplay cannot metabolise. A supporting role in a sharp film might teach more than a lavish vehicle. But the ecosystem reads anything less than immediate lead status as a loss of family rank. So young performers are denied the ordinary freedom to be mediocre in small parts while learning.

The classics also knew that faces should belong to a world. The Archies creates an Anglo-Indian Riverdale but sometimes feels socially sealed, as though everyone arrived from the same expensive grooming room. Beauty is not the problem. Uniformity is. A town becomes credible through contrasts of voice, body, age, class and temperament. Casting should expand the film’s imagination, not merely coordinate with its palette.

The defence of “audience toxicity” is incomplete

Some defenders say viewers judged the film before release because of the cast’s surnames. They are right. Social media can be vicious, misogynistic and gleefully personal. Young actors should not be abused for their families. Criticism must address the work, not bodies, accents or invented private motives. But bad-faith trolling does not invalidate good-faith judgment. An industry cannot use cruelty at the edge of discourse to avoid discussing weak performances at the centre of a film.

Another defence says streaming metrics, not critics, determine success. That is convenient because platforms disclose selective numbers and attention can come from curiosity as easily as affection. More importantly, popularity does not answer the artistic question. I am allowed to say a widely sampled film was underacted. Cinema would be impoverished if view counts became the only permitted adjective.

I also reject the idea that criticism should be gentle because these are debuts. A critic can be fair without being indulgent. I do not expect mastery from a first film, but I expect the production to know what it is selling. If the marketing presents new stars, viewers will assess star-level command. Lower the hype if you want room to grow.

What a healthier launch culture would do

First, hold genuinely open casting processes for substantial roles and publish enough about them to create trust. This will not eliminate connections, but it enlarges the pool. Second, use screen tests to cast the film rather than confirm a package. Chemistry should outrank pedigree. Third, restore apprenticeship: ensemble roles, workshops ending without guaranteed employment and projects where a newcomer is not responsible for an entire marketing campaign.

Fourth, critics and audiences should notice the less publicised actors in the same film. Nepotism survives partly because even its opponents spend all their time naming famous children. If we praise the performer who steals a scene, the market receives a signal. Outrage that keeps the privileged at the centre remains a strange form of service.

I do not wish failure on The Archies cast. I hope each actor improves and proves this judgment obsolete. That is another privilege of cinema: the next performance can revise the last. But improvement requires honest feedback, not a protective haze of fashion shoots and interviews about legacy.

Zoya Akhtar made a film with a real visual idea and an affectionate understanding of Archie Comics. I admire that ambition. I also think the film was compromised by an industry habit she was well positioned to challenge: treating access as readiness. Nepotism’s deepest advantage is not the first job. It is the elaborate system that declares the first job important before the work has earned importance, then calls criticism prejudice.

Bollywood will always contain families. I am not campaigning for hereditary exile. I am asking for standards. Let famous children audition, train, fail, support and return. Let outsiders receive the same patience after one imperfect film. And let casting directors choose the person who makes the scene live. A surname can fill the premiere. It cannot supply the flicker behind the eyes that turns a polished frame into cinema.

#the archies #bollywood #nepotism #casting

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Entertainment

View all →