indiancritic
Subscribe

The Thar Roxx’s Sensible Variant Is Buried Under Lifestyle Theatre

Mahindra has made the five-door Thar far more usable, but most buyers do not need the costliest trim or four-wheel drive. The sweet spot is the version that accepts the Roxx as a family SUV with character, not an expedition costume.

Arjun Chawla
· 6 min read
The Thar Roxx’s Sensible Variant Is Buried Under Lifestyle Theatre

Advertisement

The Mahindra Thar Roxx is what happens when an enthusiast toy acquires rear doors, a proper boot and an ambition to collect schoolchildren. It is a clever product. Mahindra did not merely stretch the three-door Thar; it created a more settled, more polished SUV while preserving the upright stance that makes neighbours peer through curtains. The Autocar India road test praised its engines, practicality and refinement while noting the compromises of a body-on-frame vehicle. My view is simpler: the Roxx is good, but the variant list invites buyers to pay for an identity they will rarely use.

Most owners need rear-wheel drive

I have driven enough four-wheel-drive vehicles to know that the transfer case is not a moral achievement. It is a tool. If you regularly tackle sand, deep mud, steep broken trails or remote mountain routes, buy the appropriate hardware and tyres, learn recovery technique and travel prepared. If your hardest obstacle is a mall ramp after monsoon rain, rear-wheel drive will manage.

Four-wheel drive adds purchase cost, mechanical complexity and weight. It may affect running costs, and its capability is wasted when tyres, clearance or driver judgment become the limiting factors. The Roxx’s tough chassis and generous clearance already make ordinary bad roads feel less threatening. A rear-driven diesel or petrol automatic will cover the lives of most urban owners without pretending Koramangala is the Karakoram.

Dealers and friends will whisper about resale. Ignore vague prophecy and calculate today’s outlay. The money saved can fund insurance, tyres, fuel and several years of maintenance. A feature you never engage is not free because a future buyer might admire the badge.

Top trims confuse equipment with value

Indian buyers are routinely pushed upward through variant ladders designed like psychological obstacle courses. The useful feature sits beside three decorative ones; the preferred engine is paired with a costly package; the showroom car glows under lights with wheels that will later meet potholes. The Roxx plays this game enthusiastically.

I like a good camera system, six airbags, stability control, automatic climate control and comfortable seats. I am less persuaded by large wheels, excessive connected features or a panoramic roof on a tall vehicle intended to shrug off rough use. Bigger wheels often mean more expensive tyres and less sidewall. A glass roof adds heat load, complexity and a potential source of rattles or leaks as the vehicle ages. It photographs beautifully. So does a hotel lobby; I do not need one attached to my car.

ADAS can be useful when well calibrated, but buyers should test it on the roads they actually use. Indian lane markings, motorcycles and unpredictable merging can turn an impressive brochure into a stream of warnings. Never choose a trim solely because it allows you to boast about a level number. Driver assistance is assistance, not absolution.

The ownership reports matter more than launch praise

A new car on a controlled route tells you about first impressions. A vehicle after thousands of kilometres tells you about marriage. Autocar’s 19,000km long-term report noted mediocre highway efficiency in its diesel automatic, a blank instrument cluster that recovered after restart, a broken air vent and the lumpy low-speed ride typical of the vehicle’s underlying architecture. Those observations do not make the Roxx unreliable by decree. They show why buyers must price character honestly.

The body-on-frame construction brings toughness and that reassuring ability to take poor surfaces in stride. It also brings movement. At urban speeds, passengers may feel the road and the rear axle more than they would in a well-tuned monocoque crossover. No amount of ambient lighting changes physics. Take your family on a long test drive over patched roads before ordering.

Fuel economy deserves equal honesty. A heavy, upright SUV with powerful engines is not going to sip like a compact hatchback. The petrol automatic will be particularly difficult to justify for high-mileage owners. Calculate fuel using a pessimistic city figure, not the number your friend achieved downhill at dawn.

Choose the powertrain for use, not folklore

The diesel suits highway distance and low-end effort, but buyers must consider their local use patterns and evolving emissions rules. Repeated short trips are not an ideal life for modern diesel after-treatment systems. The petrol is smoother and may suit lower annual mileage, though thirst can punish city use. An automatic makes sense in congestion; the manual saves money and gives direct control if you genuinely enjoy shifting.

I would identify the must-haves—safety equipment, transmission, rear camera, climate control, seat comfort—then choose the lowest trim that supplies them. Do not start at the top and negotiate emotionally downward. That is how unnecessary equipment becomes “only a little more” across several loan years.

Tyres are another point. If most driving is on tarmac, a road-biased tyre will brake better, run quieter and consume less fuel than an aggressive pattern chosen for appearance. Real off-road users can select specialised rubber with an understanding of trade-offs. Cosmetic toughness is often dynamically worse.

The Roxx is best when you stop pretending

I enjoy the view from its driver’s seat, the strong engines and the sense that a broken road will lose the argument. I appreciate the usable rear seat and luggage space that the three-door lacked. Mahindra has polished the formula enough that it can serve as a family car for owners willing to accept its size, ride and efficiency.

But a crossover will be easier for many households. It may ride more calmly in town, use less fuel, park more neatly and offer equal cabin features for less money. Buying the Roxx is rational only if you value its specific blend of image, toughness and capability. “SUV” is not automatically superior; it is a collection of compromises wearing a tall body.

Reliability and service quality must also shape the decision. Inspect the vehicle carefully at delivery, test every electronic function and document faults early. Connected screens and complex modules are wonderful until an intermittent problem sends the owner through repeated workshop visits. A simpler trim can be a quieter ownership proposition.

My money would avoid the costume department

I would choose a mid-level variant with the transmission suited to my traffic, retain sensible wheel size and skip four-wheel drive unless my calendar contained actual trails. I would spend the difference on excellent insurance, dash cameras, good tyres and preventive maintenance. That package delivers more real security than a roof full of glass and a menu of terrain animations.

The Roxx succeeds because Mahindra understood that buyers wanted Thar presence without three-door inconvenience. Its danger is that buyers may confuse the product’s broadened usefulness with a need to purchase every possible capability. The most expensive Roxx is not the most intelligent Roxx.

Buy the machine your life uses, not the person an advertisement suggests you might become. If you commute, tour with family and occasionally meet a bad road, a sensible rear-wheel-drive Roxx can be charming. If you crawl through rock and slush, equip the four-wheel-drive version properly. If you value low running costs and a settled urban ride above all, buy something else without shame.

A car is an appliance with emotional consequences. I allow emotion into the decision; otherwise we would all drive the same beige box. I simply refuse to finance theatre I cannot use. The Thar Roxx has enough character in its basic engineering. It does not need the top-trim costume to justify itself.

#mahindra thar roxx #suv #car buying #variants
Arjun Chawla

Written by

Has driven everything sold in this country and isn't impressed by half of it. Writes about value, reliability, and the trims nobody needed.

More by Arjun →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Automobiles

View all →