indiancritic
Subscribe

By Accepting a Caste Census, Modi Took Away the Opposition’s Favourite Megaphone

Including caste enumeration in Census 2027 was politically shrewd and potentially useful. The INDIA alliance wanted a permanent grievance campaign; the government answered it with a national statistical exercise that must now be protected from quota arithmetic and slogan merchants.

Meenakshi Iyer
· 7 min read
By Accepting a Caste Census, Modi Took Away the Opposition’s Favourite Megaphone
Prime Minister's Office / GODL-India

Advertisement

For years, the opposition’s caste-census pitch operated less like a policy proposal and more like a chant designed to end discussion. Ask how categories would be defined, how data would be checked, or what programmes would follow, and one was accused of fearing social justice. Then the Modi government agreed to include caste enumeration in the coming census. The Cabinet decision was recorded in an official April 2025 release. A remarkable thing followed: several people who had demanded the exercise immediately found new reasons to complain. That reaction told me the campaign had always been partly about owning a grievance, not merely obtaining data.

A sensible concession, not an ideological surrender

I support the decision because a modern welfare state should know the society it is trying to serve. India relies on old assumptions, uneven state surveys and administrative categories created for different purposes. Better data can reveal whether benefits reach intended communities, where educational gaps persist and which groups have escaped political attention. Refusing to count does not abolish caste. It merely ensures that loud organisations and electoral brokers possess more influence than evidence.

The government was right to place the exercise inside the national census rather than bless a collection of partisan state surveys as substitutes. Census machinery has uniform protocols, legal protections and national coverage. That does not make it infallible; classification will be extremely difficult. It does, however, provide a better foundation than hurried questionnaires designed near an election. The central state also has the capacity to build a code directory, train enumerators and publish methodology that can be scrutinised.

The official timetable says Census 2027 is to be conducted in phases, with population enumeration and caste enumeration forming part of the later exercise. A government background document describes the digital design, confidentiality protections and scale of the operation in its Census 2027 overview. Those dry details matter more than television rhetoric. Social data become legitimate through careful definitions, secure collection and honest disclosure of limitations—not through a politician waving a percentage at a rally.

The INDIA alliance wanted a slogan without engineering

Rahul Gandhi and allied parties successfully made caste enumeration a national political demand. They deserve acknowledgment for forcing attention onto the data gap. But their framing has often been intellectually lazy. “Count and distribute” sounds decisive until one asks what is being distributed, according to which measure, with what constitutional constraints and at whose expense. Population share is not a complete theory of justice. Need, deprivation, geographic disadvantage, discrimination and access to public goods do not collapse into a single caste column.

The commentariat treated every request for detail as proof of elite panic. That is classic Lutyens reasoning: first declare one moral vocabulary permissible, then diagnose questions as bad faith. Yet the hard questions will determine whether the census helps anyone. Will respondents supply jati, sub-caste or a broader label? How will variant spellings be reconciled? How will enumerators handle claims that do not match existing lists? When will raw data become usable tables? What privacy safeguards will prevent household information from becoming local political currency?

A responsible opposition would now engage those problems. Instead, much of it has moved to demanding deadlines, outcomes and numerical promises before enumeration is complete. That is not evidence-based policy; it is an attempt to pre-book the interpretation. If the resulting data are trusted only when they validate a party’s preferred narrative, the whole exercise becomes an expensive prop.

The BJP’s political calculation is legitimate

Of course the decision has politics in it. Governments make consequential decisions in political contexts. The BJP saw that resisting the demand allowed opponents to portray it as hostile to backward-class representation, despite its own broad social coalition and extensive welfare politics. By agreeing to a national count, it denied Congress a monopoly over the language of social justice. I do not find this sinister. Democratic competition is supposed to make parties respond to demands.

The clever part is that the decision aligns political defence with administrative usefulness. Modi has often succeeded by absorbing an opponent’s issue, changing its scale and attaching it to state capacity. The census can do that here. Rather than a series of rallies announcing speculative numbers, India can attempt a nationwide dataset. The government should take credit, but it must not overmarket the exercise before the difficult work is done.

There is a risk for the BJP as well. Caste data may unsettle alliances, expose uneven representation or create demands that cannot all be met. Some supporters will dislike the emphasis on identities that the party’s broader Hindu coalition tries to bridge. Pretending those tensions do not exist would be foolish. Leadership means accepting a useful exercise even when the numbers might inconvenience you. If the government publishes credible results rather than burying awkward tables, it will have earned trust beyond its base.

Data must not become destiny

My central warning is that enumeration should not turn every citizen into a fraction in a permanent spoils calculation. The state needs group data because discrimination and inherited deprivation are real. Individuals also possess aspirations that exceed their categories. A young person should not be told that every university seat, job, loan and political office is merely a community entitlement to be divided by population share.

The census should therefore inform a wider dashboard: school completion, landholding, urban mobility, household assets, health access and regional opportunity. Caste alone cannot tell us whether a policy works. Two families carrying the same label may live radically different lives in Bihar and Maharashtra, or in a village and a metropolitan suburb. If parties reduce a complex dataset to one national league table, they will make the country angrier without making policy smarter.

The government should publish the questionnaire, classification principles and error-handling process early enough for expert review. It should create an independent statistical advisory group and release anonymised aggregate data in stages. It must clearly explain that personal census information is confidential. Rumour thrives when the state communicates late, and caste entrepreneurs will eagerly fill any vacuum with claims that a household’s answer determines an immediate benefit.

I would also like Parliament to debate what the census can and cannot legitimately settle. Reservation policy involves constitutional law, court judgments, administrative capacity and competing forms of disadvantage. A count is an input, not an automatic verdict. Anyone promising that a table will resolve those questions is selling arithmetic as politics.

The outrage machine has lost an easy script

What amused me most was watching commentators struggle after the announcement. The stock story had been that the government feared data and the opposition alone represented the marginalised. Once the Cabinet accepted enumeration, the script required emergency repairs. Some called the decision belated; others treated implementation questions as proof of sabotage before fieldwork began. A government can be criticised for delay, certainly, but “you did what we demanded too late” is not evidence that the decision itself is wrong.

Congress should claim its share of credit for raising the subject and then help make the census robust. The BJP should resist triumphalism and deliver. Civil society should examine design rather than manufacture daily outrage. Those roles would produce a better dataset than the current contest to declare betrayal in advance.

I favour the census because information is preferable to mythology. I favour the government’s approach because a uniform national exercise is preferable to a patchwork of politically branded surveys. And I remain sceptical of the INDIA alliance because too many of its leaders speak as if counting citizens completes the work of governing them. The real test begins after the totals arrive: can India target disadvantage without freezing society into competing hereditary blocs? Modi has removed the opposition’s favourite megaphone. He must now prove that the quieter work of statistics can serve citizens better than the slogan ever did.

#caste census #census 2027 #social justice #opposition
Meenakshi Iyer

Written by

Tired of Lutyens Delhi's chosen narratives. Calls out manufactured outrage from the INDIA alliance and the commentariat that amplifies it for what it is.

More by Meenakshi →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Indian Politics

View all →