I have a mildly antisocial habit: I read Budget documents before television panels tell me what they supposedly mean. This saves time. It also makes one less vulnerable to the annual pantomime in which every tax change is either declared a historic revolution or dismissed as crumbs. The personal income-tax changes announced in the 2025 Union Budget deserved a calmer judgment. By proposing that resident individuals using the new regime pay no income tax on ordinary income up to ₹12 lakh through the rebate, while also revising the slabs, the Modi government made a serious choice: let the salaried middle class retain more of its incremental earnings and make the default system easier to understand. The exact structure appears in the government’s official Budget speech. I think the direction is plainly right, even if the reform remains unfinished.
Relief is not the same as populism
The predictable criticism is that tax relief for salaried households is an electoral sweetener. That charge is wonderfully convenient because it can be made about any measure voters like. Yet a tax cut is not identical to a cash handout. The state is not granting citizens a favour from some celestial treasury; it is taking less of what they earned. That distinction matters. A household that keeps more salary can decide whether to repay a loan, buy an appliance, pay school fees, build an emergency fund or invest. A ministry cannot know which choice is most useful to that family, and it should show some humility about trying.
The revised slabs also improve incentives at the margin. A system should not make a modest raise feel like a bureaucratic trap. The Budget placed the nil slab up to ₹4 lakh, followed by rates that rise in steps until the top rate is reached above ₹24 lakh. The rebate and marginal-relief provisions require care, but the overall ladder is easier to explain than the thicket India had normalised. Simplicity has economic value. It reduces calculation anxiety, dependence on last-minute tax advice and the suspicion that only people with elaborate deductions can obtain a fair result.
I know the counterargument: the old regime rewarded insurance, home loans and certain savings, while the new one may weaken those habits. There is truth in that. India does need long-term household savings, and housing carries large spillovers. But a tax code should not force every family into the same financial costume. A young renter in Bengaluru, a couple supporting elderly parents in Jaipur and a homeowner in Lucknow do not have identical needs. Let products compete on merit rather than survive because the tax department nudges citizens toward them.
The Congress critique avoids its own record
Congress politicians often speak as though India once possessed a beautifully progressive, predictable tax system that the present government vandalised. I remember a different inheritance: proliferating exemptions, adversarial administration, retrospective uncertainty and a political culture in which honest salaried taxpayers were treated as an inexhaustible captive base. Congress-era nostalgia is not a tax policy. Saying “inequality” repeatedly does not answer what rate a teacher, engineer or shop manager should pay, how many forms they should file, or why a promotion ought to create a disproportionate compliance burden.
The left-leaning response has another oddity. Its advocates want a larger formal economy, better compliance and fewer cash transactions, yet frequently resist measures that make formal participation feel worthwhile. Tax morale is not built only through enforcement. It grows when citizens can understand the bargain. If rates and rules appear reasonable, filing becomes less like punishment for being visible. The government deserves credit for recognising that legitimacy matters alongside collections.
None of this means the Budget settled every issue. The tax base remains narrow relative to the size of the population. Indirect taxes still affect households regardless of income. Local public services often fail to give taxpayers a visible return. The government must also resist the temptation to reintroduce complexity through surcharges, exceptions and frequent rule changes. A clean slab chart can be made dirty again through a dozen circulars. Reform is a discipline, not a launch event.
What the government should do next
First, it should make the new regime genuinely stable. Households plan over years, not press conferences. Announcing a coherent medium-term path for slabs, indexation and filing rules would be more valuable than producing a surprise every February. Inflation should not quietly drag ordinary earners into higher effective burdens while politicians congratulate themselves for leaving nominal thresholds untouched.
Second, the administration should publish plain examples covering salary, bank interest, capital gains and common deductions. The Budget document provides illustrations of the proposed benefit, but taxpayers encounter mixed income, employer benefits and small investments in real life. A two-page calculator-friendly guide is better governance than a hundred-page clarification after confusion spreads. The Income Tax Department’s digital systems have improved, yet ease of filing must be measured by the experience of a non-specialist, not by the pride of the software vendor.
Third, the government should continue reducing pointless disputes. A lower liability means little if a citizen spends months responding to an automated mismatch over a small sum. Data-driven administration should distinguish likely evasion from a clerical difference. The government has talked consistently about trust-based compliance; taxpayers will judge that promise when a notice arrives, not when a minister uses the phrase.
There is also a fiscal question. Tax relief cannot become an excuse to neglect capital expenditure or borrow carelessly. The strongest case for the reform is that it sits beside, rather than replaces, investment in roads, railways, logistics and digital public infrastructure. A government that both builds capacity and leaves households more disposable income can support supply and demand. One that merely distributes money without improving productive capacity eventually sends the bill back through inflation.
A reform worth defending without worshipping
I am not claiming every rupee retained will become virtuous consumption or investment. Some will buy imported gadgets; some will sit in low-yield accounts; some households will barely notice the difference. Citizens are allowed to make imperfect choices with their own money. The state’s burden is to justify taking it, not the citizen’s burden to prove an approved use for keeping it.
The government’s own Budget-at-a-glance material on direct-tax proposals frames the change as middle-class relief. That description is accurate but incomplete. The deeper reform is philosophical: a simpler tax system should treat rising income as progress, not an opportunity to surround the earner with traps. India wants people to formalise, earn more and declare it. The rules must stop making those actions feel naïve.
My reservation is political. Once a threshold becomes a slogan, future governments may freeze it long after inflation erodes its meaning, or compete through arbitrary rebates instead of structural reform. The answer is not to reject today’s relief. It is to demand that the architecture remain rational, broad and predictable. Parliament should debate the design rather than stage the usual contest between applause and theatrical outrage.
For now, the change deserves more than the grudging acknowledgment it has received from commentators who would have praised it as compassionate modernisation had a Congress finance minister proposed it. The Modi government has taken a meaningful step toward a tax regime suited to aspiration rather than scarcity. I give it credit for that. I also expect it to finish the job: fewer exceptions, fewer disputes, stable rules and a visible return on the taxes that remain. That is not sycophancy. It is the standard reformers should welcome.



