indiancritic
Subscribe

The Budget’s Boring Capex Discipline Is Exactly the Reform Congress Cannot Mimic

I would have liked a faster deficit reduction, but the government’s decision to preserve public investment while consolidating gradually is more serious than another round of slogan-heavy redistribution.

Aditya Rao
· 6 min read
The Budget’s Boring Capex Discipline Is Exactly the Reform Congress Cannot Mimic
Moheen Reeyad / CC BY-SA 4.0

Advertisement

I have a confession that will not improve my standing at dinner parties: I read the fiscal responsibility statement before I read most Budget commentary. Television panels supply adjectives within minutes; the tables reveal what a government is actually willing to fund. In the Union Budget for 2026-27, the useful number is not hidden in a catchy acronym. The Centre has budgeted ₹12.22 lakh crore for capital expenditure and ₹17.15 lakh crore in effective capital expenditure, according to the government’s fiscal policy statement. That is the dull machinery of roads, railways, logistics, urban assets and state-level projects. I think preserving it while continuing fiscal consolidation is the correct choice.

The familiar criticism is that the government has become addicted to announcing large infrastructure totals while households need relief now. That objection deserves an answer, not a sneer. Consumption has been uneven, employment quality remains a concern and food inflation can make a respectable headline growth rate feel theoretical to a salaried or lower-income family. I would have welcomed sharper tax simplification and a more aggressive attack on the costs that make formal employment unattractive. Yet the Congress remedy is too often an expanding catalogue of entitlements presented as if the financing were an accounting nuisance. It mistakes immediate visibility for durable value.

Investment is not an elitist abstraction

A highway is not automatically good policy, and a railway station is not virtuous merely because it photographs well. The test is whether an asset reduces travel time, moves freight more cheaply, crowds in private investment or extends a useful public service. That is why I care about project selection, maintenance and completion, not merely sanctioned outlay. Still, the broad capex turn of the Modi years corrected an older weakness: India spent too much political energy distributing a modest economic pie and too little building the productive capacity that could enlarge it.

The Budget’s own Budget at a Glance places total expenditure at ₹53.47 lakh crore and capital expenditure at ₹12.22 lakh crore. Those are enormous commitments, which is precisely why scrutiny matters. But critics who describe every expressway, freight corridor or capital grant to states as corporate welfare are refusing to see how ordinary Indians use public infrastructure. The factory worker riding a regional train, the small manufacturer paying less for logistics and the farmer reaching a market on a dependable road are not footnotes to some billionaire’s balance sheet.

Public investment also has a different economic character from a permanent revenue promise. A well-chosen asset can raise productivity over decades. A poorly designed recurring subsidy becomes politically difficult to reform even when its original purpose has expired. I am not arguing that welfare should disappear. India still needs nutrition support, health protection and targeted help for households facing genuine deprivation. I am arguing that a government should distinguish a safety net from a governing philosophy. Congress’s nostalgic sales pitch often erases that distinction.

The fiscal path deserves credit—and pressure

The government estimates the fiscal deficit at 4.3 per cent of GDP for 2026-27. I would prefer a quicker descent, particularly because interest payments consume fiscal space that could finance defence modernisation, courts, policing and municipal reform. Debt consolidation cannot remain tomorrow’s virtue. A country with India’s ambitions should not treat every additional tenth of a percentage point of borrowing as painless merely because growth is respectable.

There is also a legitimate implementation question. Budget estimates are intentions, not bridges. Ministries must acquire land lawfully, coordinate utilities, enforce contracts and publish completion data that taxpayers can understand. State capacity remains maddeningly uneven. Some projects are delayed by litigation or poor preparation; others are inaugurated before the last-mile ecosystem is ready. Giving the government credit for the capex strategy does not require pretending that every project is efficient. In my view, the next reform must be a public dashboard that compares original cost, revised cost, completion date and measurable economic outcome for major projects.

Yet this is where the opposition’s critique becomes unserious. It rarely offers a better project-appraisal regime or a cleaner procurement architecture. Instead, it jumps from a delayed project to the claim that the entire investment model is a favour to a few industrial groups. That may be emotionally convenient, but it is not a governing alternative. If Congress believes capex is misallocated, it should publish a shadow infrastructure plan: what it would cancel, what it would retain and how it would finance its guarantees at the same time.

States should be partners, not alibis

The Centre’s capital support to states is important because much of the infrastructure Indians experience is delivered below the Union level. But states cannot demand more unconditional money while resisting transparent milestones. Nor should the Centre use centrally sponsored schemes to turn chief ministers into implementing contractors for Delhi. The principled approach is clear: stable transfers, measurable outcomes, room for local design and consequences for chronic non-performance.

This point also exposes the laziness of the federalism debate. Opposition parties routinely call a condition attached to public money an assault on federalism, then ask the Centre to accept blame for weak execution. The BJP is not innocent of centralising instincts, and I think it sometimes packages cooperative federalism too much like brand management. Still, a rupee transferred without a credible audit is not federalism; it is evasion. Citizens deserve to know which level of government made a promise, controlled the money and failed to deliver.

The capex model must now become more urban. India’s cities need sewage networks, buses, drainage, rental housing, street design and financially competent municipalities. Monumental projects attract attention, but a functioning storm-water drain produces a better life. I would gladly trade a few ceremonial announcements for reforms that let cities levy sensible user charges, update property rolls and borrow against credible revenue. The Union government has the leverage to push this, and it should use it.

What the opposition still refuses to learn

The Modi government’s political strength is not simply communication, though its communication is formidable. It is the ability to combine visible welfare delivery with a story of national capacity. Congress keeps trying to answer that with nostalgia for a supposedly gentler era and promises whose arithmetic is left for after the rally. Voters are entitled to ask a rude question: if the old model was so humane and competent, why did India tolerate such poor infrastructure for so long?

That does not mean every BJP spending choice is wise. I remain unconvinced by subsidies that protect inefficient producers indefinitely, and I dislike retrospective claims of success based solely on outlay. The government should publish stronger independent evaluations and close programmes that do not work. Reform credibility comes from admitting failure as well as celebrating scale.

But the central choice remains straightforward. India can protect productive investment while reducing the deficit gradually, or it can return to the politics in which every organised constituency receives a promise and future taxpayers receive the bill. I choose the first. It is less sentimental, less televisual and more likely to leave the next generation an asset rather than an excuse. For once, boring budget discipline is the genuinely ambitious position.

#union budget #capital expenditure #fiscal policy #infrastructure
Aditya Rao

Written by

Reads budget documents for fun and gives the government credit for the reforms the opposition would rather not discuss. No patience for Congress-era nostalgia dressed up as policy.

More by Aditya →

Advertisement

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

More in Indian Politics

View all →